 |
| Andrew Scott takes the title role as con man Tom Ripley |
The Netflix TV drama Ripley, based on Patricia Highsmith's novels, is stirring up mixed reviews from critics. The show features Andrew Scott as the fraudulent protagonist.
Critics' Opinions
The Guardian's Praise
- Lucy Mangan from The Guardian gives the show five stars, praising Scott's performance as "absolutely spellbinding."
Variety's Critique
- Amaride Tinubu from Variety finds Scott "utterly charmless" in the role of Tom Ripley.
Plot Summary
- Set in 1960s New York, Ripley follows Scott's portrayal of the ruthless Tom Ripley, sent to Italy to persuade a shipping magnate's son to return home.
Comparison to Previous Adaptations
- Previous adaptations include the Oscar-nominated 1999 film The Talented Mr Ripley. The new version stars Dakota Fanning as Marge and Johnny Flynn as Dickie.
Lucy Mangan's Perspective
- Mangan describes the adaptation as "scintillating and noirish," praising Scott's portrayal and the fresh execution of the plot.
Amaride Tinubu's Perspective
- Tinubu criticizes the show for lacking seduction and likability, comparing it unfavorably to previous adaptations.
Adam White's Assessment
- White views Scott as miscast but finds the adaptation decent overall, though haunted by past versions.
Carole Midgley's Review
- Midgley lauds the show as "a Hitchcockian work of art," particularly praising Scott's performance.
Steven Zaillian's Direction
- The series is written and directed by Steven Zaillian, known for his work on acclaimed films.
Daniel Fienberg's Analysis
- Fienberg praises Scott's performance but notes his age as a potential issue. He suggests further installments could be warranted.
John Nugent's Evaluation
- Nugent highlights Scott's departure from previous interpretations of Ripley and praises the show's ambition.
Roxana Hadadi's Perspective
- Hadadi commends Scott's portrayal and describes the adaptation as "deliciously mean."
Christopher Stevens' Review
- Stevens awards the series five stars, emphasizing Scott's ability to provoke moral reflection.
Conclusion
- Ripley receives a range of reviews, with praise for Scott's performance and the show's ambition, but criticism for aspects such as likability and fidelity to the source material.
Tags:
Entertainment